Fractional GC

Insights — Governance

The Legal Note in the Board Pack: Writing Advice Directors Can Act On

A legal note that restates the law is of little use to a board deciding what to do. This article sets out what directors actually need from legal advice, how to structure a note, and why the minute matters as much as the advice.

What a board actually needs from legal

Directors are not asking what the law says. They are asking three questions: what are the options, what does each one cost or risk, and what would a reasonable board do. Advice that answers those questions gets used. Advice that recites statute gets noted and filed.

The distinction matters because a board's duty is to exercise judgement on an informed basis. A note that describes a legal position without translating it into choices leaves the board exactly where it started, with an additional document and no clearer view.

The most useful legal notes are short. One page of analysis, one page of options, and a clear statement of what the adviser recommends and why. Everything else belongs in an appendix.

The difference between advice and assurance

Advice says what the adviser thinks will happen and what should be done. Assurance says that a course of action is lawful or that a process was properly followed. Boards often want assurance, because it feels like protection, and advisers are sometimes too willing to give it.

The honest position is usually that a course of action carries a risk which can be described and managed but not eliminated. A board told that plainly can make a decision and record it. A board told that everything is fine has been given nothing it can rely on later.

Where assurance genuinely can be given, it should be specific: this step is compliant with this requirement, on these facts. General assurances are worth very little when tested.

Structuring the note

Open with the decision required and the deadline for making it. Then the facts relied on, briefly, because the advice is only as good as the facts and the board needs to see whether they are right. Then the options, each with its consequences.

Then the recommendation, and the reasons for it. Then the risks that remain, and what would change the analysis. Finally the steps that must be taken if the board decides to proceed, with who is responsible for each.

That structure has one further advantage: it makes the note usable as a minute. A board that records the options considered, the advice received and the reasons for its decision has done most of what it needs to do.

The minute that protects the decision

Boards tend to record conclusions and not reasoning. Years later, if a decision is challenged, the reasoning is what demonstrates that the directors thought about it. A minute that records only that a resolution was passed proves very little.

Record the material that was before the board, the questions asked, the answers given and the basis on which the decision was taken. Where a director dissented, record it. None of this is defensive drafting; it is the ordinary evidence of proper governance.

A general counsel's most durable contribution to a board is often not the advice itself but the habit of ensuring that advice, decision and record are consistent with one another.

Talk it through with a general counsel

A 30-minute, no-obligation conversation. No pitch and no pressure, just a straight answer on what your business needs and what it should cost.

Book an appointment

Burns & Co. GC is part of Burns & Co. Group — a group of specialist consultancy, investment and charitable initiatives.

Learn more about the Burns & Co. Group

Head office: 375 London Road, Benfleet, SS7 2BT

Registered office: 86-90 Paul Street, London, EC2A 4NE

Also at 8 Bishopsgate, London, EC2N 4BQ · 17 Hanover Square, London, W1S 1BN · 16 Market Street, Chipping Norton, OX7 5NA · Audley End Business Centre, Saffron Walden, CB11 4JL

Burns & Co. GC is a trading style of Burns and Company Professional Limited. Burns and Company Professional Limited provides reserved legal services through firms which are authorised and regulated by the Solicitors Regulation Authority, and noted on the Financial Conduct Authority register for insurance distribution purposes.

© 2026 Burns & Co. Group