Opinion

Business rates are a tax on the high street, and we should say so plainly

A shop pays its rates whether it trades or not, whether the pavement outside is closed or not, whether the customers come or not. My view on the least defensible tax in the country.

Opinion20 November 2026 · 6 min read

By Joe Burns

The bill that arrives regardless

Business rates are a property tax collected from occupiers, calculated by reference to a rateable value that reflects what the premises could be let for at a valuation date that can be years behind the market. The occupier pays whether the business is profitable or not, whether the building is full or empty, whether the road outside is open or dug up for the third time in two years.

I have sat with enough shopkeepers, publicans and small manufacturers to know what that means in practice. It is the bill that arrives before the first customer of the year, and it does not care how the year goes. Every other cost a business carries responds, eventually, to trading. This one does not.

That is not an argument against property taxation. It is an argument for being honest about what this particular tax does, and to whom.

Why it lands hardest on the high street

A warehouse on the edge of town pays rates on a building that is cheap per square foot and busy every hour it is open. A shop in a town centre pays rates on a building that is expensive per square foot and busy for part of the day, in a location whose footfall is partly determined by decisions the shopkeeper does not make: parking charges, bus routes, street works, the closing of the bank branch, the state of the pavements.

Add rent, staff, energy and insurance, and the fixed costs of a high street unit arrive before a single item is sold. The online competitor with a distribution shed and a website carries a fraction of that fixed burden per pound of turnover. Whatever one thinks about the shift to online, the tax system has been pushing in the same direction for fifteen years.

The result is visible in every town I visit: units that stay empty because the rates on them exceed what a marginal business could hope to earn, and landlords who would rather hold an empty building than subsidise a tenant's rates bill.

What a vacancy does to a town

An empty shop is not neutral. It reduces footfall for the shops around it, which reduces their trade, which makes the next unit more likely to close. The rates still fall due on the empty property after the initial relief period, so the owner has an incentive to hold out for a tenant rather than accept a lower rent, and the street stays empty for longer.

The cost then moves to the public purse anyway: less business rates collected overall, fewer jobs, more spent on services for a town centre in decline. A tax designed to fund local services ends up taxing the places that need those services most, until they need them more.

I do not think anyone designed it to work this way. That is rather the point. It has been left to work this way for so long that the effect is now treated as inevitable.

What I would change

First, rebalance the burden. If the tax is meant to fall on property occupation, it should fall consistently across the kinds of property a modern economy uses, rather than most heavily on the kind that creates the most employment per square foot in the places that need it most.

Second, value properties more often. A system that relies on valuations that lag the market by years produces bills that are wrong in both directions, and leaves businesses unable to plan. Frequent, cheaper revaluations with transitional relief that actually smooths the change would be fairer than the current cycle.

Third, treat empty property sensibly. Relief that encourages a landlord to keep a unit empty is relief in the wrong direction. The aim should be occupancy, and the tax should be designed to encourage it rather than to punish the landlord who accepts a lower rent to get a tenant in.

Fourth, be honest about the transition. Any rebalancing creates winners and losers, and the losers will be vocal. That is a reason to plan the transition carefully, not a reason to avoid it.

Why I am writing this

I advise businesses that occupy commercial property, and I see the rates bill in their accounts every week. I also see what happens to a town when the shops close, and how quickly the closure of a bank, a pharmacy and a supermarket changes the character of a place that people were proud of.

This is not nostalgia for a retail model that has gone. It is a straightforward point about incentives. If we want high streets to keep working, the cost of occupying a unit on one has to bear some relation to the trade that unit can realistically do. At the moment it does not, and the bill arrives regardless.

I would rather say that plainly than keep pretending the decline is nobody's policy.