The gain, calculated properly
Capital gains tax on commercial property is charged on the difference between the disposal proceeds and the base cost, less allowable expenditure. The base cost is what you paid for the property, plus the costs of acquisition — stamp duty land tax, legal fees, survey fees — plus capital expenditure on improvements that has not already been relieved.
The proceeds are the sale price, less the costs of disposal: agent's fees, legal fees, and any costs of establishing the title. Enhancement expenditure, such as an extension or a new roof, is allowable if it is reflected in the asset at the time of sale; repairs and maintenance are not.
The arithmetic sounds simple and frequently is not, particularly where the property has been held for decades, has been let and used for business at different times, or has been transferred between connected parties. Records matter more than memory, and HMRC will ask for them.
The rates and the reliefs
Companies pay corporation tax on chargeable gains at the prevailing rate. Individuals and partnerships pay capital gains tax, with residential property and carried interest subject to different rates from other assets, and the rate depends on the taxpayer's other income and the size of the gain.
Business Asset Disposal Relief can apply to disposals of business assets, including commercial property used in a trade, where the conditions are met — but it is limited in lifetime value and the qualifying requirements are specific. It should be tested rather than assumed, and the test should happen before the sale is structured.
Where the property has been used partly for business and partly for letting, or where it has been held through a company and the shares are being sold rather than the building, the analysis changes completely. Rollover relief, holdover relief, and the interaction with inheritance tax and business property relief all need to be considered together.
The sixty-day reporting rule
For residential property, and for any disposal that produces a gain on UK land, the return and payment on account are due within sixty days of completion. That deadline is short, the penalty for missing it is automatic, and it applies even where the taxpayer expects to report the gain in a self assessment return later.
The practical consequence is that the seller needs the completion statement, the base cost figures and the allowable expenditure ready before completion, not after. A solicitor who has been told the acquisition cost and has the old completion statement can prepare the figures quickly. A seller who has to reconstruct a purchase from 1998 will not.
Where no gain arises, a return may still be required if the proceeds exceed the reporting threshold. The safest approach is to assume a return is needed and confirm with the accountant.
Structuring before the sale
If the property is held in a company, selling the shares rather than the building may be more tax-efficient for the seller and less attractive to the buyer, who loses the ability to claim relief on the purchase price. That tension is the heart of most property deal structures, and it is worth modelling both routes before heads of terms.
If the property is held personally and used by a company the seller owns, the relationship between the two — the lease, the rent, the occupation — affects the reliefs available. So does the timing of any transfer between them.
If a sale is likely within a few years, consider the position now: the base cost evidence, the capital expenditure records, the use of the property over time and the ownership structure. Planning before a buyer appears is worth considerably more than planning after.
Working with your advisers
We do not give tax advice, but we work alongside accountants on property disposals constantly, and the legal documents have tax consequences: how the price is apportioned between building, land, fixtures and goodwill; whether VAT is charged; whether the contract includes a condition that affects the completion date and therefore the tax year of disposal.
The most efficient sales are ones where the solicitor and the accountant are instructed at the same time, with the same information. That way the contract is drafted to reflect the tax position rather than the tax position being reconstructed from the contract.
If you are selling commercial property, we can handle the legal work and coordinate with your accountant on the figures the sixty-day deadline requires.