The claim and its basis
Dilapidations are the landlord's claim for the cost of putting the premises back into the condition the lease requires at the end of the term. It is usually the tenant's largest single cost in a commercial lease after rent, and it is entirely governed by how the repairing obligation was drafted when the lease was signed.
A full repairing and insuring obligation requires the tenant to keep the premises in repair and to yield them up in that state. On a lease with no schedule of condition, the standard is often 'in good and substantial repair', which can require the tenant to remedy disrepair that existed before it took the premises. That is why the schedule is the single most valuable document a tenant can insist on.
The wording also matters. 'Repair' is not the same as 'renew' or 'improve', and a landlord cannot use the dilapidations machinery to upgrade the building at the tenant's expense. A claim for replacement of a worn component may be limited to the cost of repair, or to a proportionate contribution reflecting the age and condition of what was replaced.
Statutory and practical limits
For leases of business premises, statute limits a landlord's claim to the diminution in the value of the reversion — the loss in the value of the landlord's interest caused by the disrepair — capped at the cost of the works. A landlord who claims for a full refurbishment that the property does not need will struggle to establish the loss.
There are also procedural requirements. A landlord must normally serve a notice specifying the repairs, and give the tenant a reasonable opportunity to do the work, before issuing proceedings. Sending a schedule of dilapidations is not the same as a notice, and the distinction is worth knowing if a demand arrives at the end of the term.
Timing matters commercially. A claim pursued years after the lease ends, when the works have been done as part of a refurbishment, is harder to justify and easier to resist. A claim served promptly and supported by a surveyor's schedule is much harder to argue with.
The tenant's position before the end
The best time to deal with dilapidations is at the start, with a schedule of condition attached to the lease and expressly limiting the repairing obligation. The second best time is twelve to eighteen months before the end of the term, when a surveyor can prepare a costed assessment and the tenant can decide whether to do the works or negotiate a cash settlement.
Doing the work yourself is frequently cheaper than paying the landlord's contractor, and a tenant who carries out the repairs to the lease standard has discharged the obligation. The catch is that the work must be done before the term ends, and it must be the right work — a repair that does not satisfy the schedule has achieved nothing.
Negotiating a financial settlement is often the practical answer, particularly where the landlord intends to refurbish anyway. That conversation should be supported by a surveyor's assessment of the actual diminution in value, not by the landlord's schedule of costs.
Reinstatement and alterations
Separate from repair is reinstatement: removing alterations, signage, partitions, cabling and equipment installed during the term. The lease and any licence for alterations decide whether removal is required, and a licence that permits an alteration on condition it is removed at the end effectively defers the cost to the end of the term.
Tenants should keep every licence for alterations and track the reinstatement conditions as they go. A tenant that has spent a decade accumulating fit-out and cannot demonstrate what was approved for what condition is in a weak position at exit.
Where a break clause requires vacant possession, the reinstatement obligation and the break conditions interact and must be sequenced carefully. The tenant who plans the exit eighteen months out usually pays substantially less than the tenant who reacts to a schedule of dilapidations in the final month.