Why earn-outs exist
An earn-out is the part of the price paid after completion, calculated by reference to how the business performs over a defined period — usually turnover, gross profit or EBITDA over one to three years. It bridges the gap between what a seller believes the business is worth and what a buyer is willing to pay today.
The attraction is obvious: the seller gets a full price if the business performs, the buyer pays more only if the value they bought actually arrives. The difficulty is equally obvious. After completion the seller usually no longer controls the business, yet their remaining money depends on how it is run.
That asymmetry is the whole legal problem of an earn-out. A well-drafted clause does not remove it; it allocates it. The drafting has to decide, in advance, what counts as performance, how it is measured, and how the business must be run while the clock is running.
Defining the target
The first job is a definition precise enough for an accountant to apply without argument. Revenue is rarely the right measure on its own, because it can be bought with discounting. EBITDA is common but depends on add-backs — owner's remuneration, exceptional costs, group charges — and every one of those is a negotiating point.
The measurement period matters just as much. Twelve months avoids seasonality problems, but a business that trades in cycles may distort a single year. Three years smooths the cycle but keeps the seller exposed for longer. Where a business is growing, the parties should also decide whether the target is fixed, stepped or cumulative.
Then deal with the accounting mechanics: which accounting policies apply (the buyer's, the seller's, or a stated set), whether the buyer's own group charges are deducted, and how a dispute is resolved — usually by an independent accountant acting as expert rather than arbitrator, so that a disagreement cannot become litigation.
Protecting the business after completion
Because the seller no longer runs the business, the agreement needs covenants on how the buyer will run it during the earn-out period. These typically require the buyer to operate the business in the ordinary course, maintain working capital at agreed levels, keep the sales team and the brand, and not take steps designed to suppress the earn-out.
An anti-frustration covenant is the heart of it: the buyer must not divert orders to another group company, move customers, cut marketing to improve a group margin, or reorganise the business to avoid the target. Where the buyer wants freedom to integrate, that freedom must be priced in at the outset, not discovered afterwards.
The seller should also keep some information rights for the period — management accounts, a copy of the earn-out calculation and the right to challenge it within a set time. Without those, a seller is asked to accept a number they cannot check.
Security and acceleration
An unsecured promise to pay in two years is only as good as the buyer's balance sheet, and buyers are often special purpose vehicles with very little behind them. Security matters: a loan note, a parent company guarantee, a charge over shares or assets, or a set-off against the buyer's other obligations.
Acceleration clauses protect the seller if the ground shifts. Typical triggers are the sale of the business or the buyer's group during the earn-out period, an insolvency event, or a breach of the anti-frustration covenants. On acceleration the seller wants the balance paid in full, or calculated on a fair basis, rather than the arrangement simply falling away.
Finally, the seller should understand their own tax position before agreeing the split between completion and deferred sums, which is a conversation with their accountant. Our role is to make the earn-out enforceable, measurable and secure, rather than merely described. If you are negotiating a deal with deferred consideration, we can review the mechanism before you sign.