Why clearance exists
Several tax rules are designed to catch arrangements that have no purpose other than avoiding tax. They are drawn widely, and a genuine commercial transaction can fall within them if it happens to have the shape they describe. Clearance is the mechanism by which HMRC confirms in advance that it will not challenge the tax treatment of a transaction.
For a business sale or reorganisation, the clearance is often the difference between a deal that works and one that produces an unexpected tax bill a year later. It is not a guarantee of the tax outcome in every respect, and it does not bind HMRC if the facts were misdescribed, but it removes the principal risk.
The cost of a clearance application is small against the value of the relief it protects, and the main constraint is time. HMRC's published target is around 28 days for most applications, but it is frequently longer, and a deal that leaves clearance to the week before completion is a deal that may not complete.
The clearances that arise most often
Where a company is being sold through a share-for-share exchange, or a group is being reorganised before sale, a clearance under section 138 of the Taxation of Chargeable Gains Act 1992 asks HMRC to confirm that the reconstruction will not be treated as a disposal for capital gains purposes. Without it, the shareholders may face a charge on an exchange that was never intended to produce cash.
Section 701 of the Corporation Tax Act 2010 deals with transactions in securities, and clearance confirms that the intended tax advantage will not be counteracted. Section 748 of the same Act applies to share-for-share exchanges involving companies. Demergers have their own clearance route, and it is usually the longest to obtain.
There is also a general non-statutory clearance service for transactions where the tax treatment is genuinely uncertain and the answer is not clear from published guidance. It is not a substitute for advice and it will not be given on a point HMRC considers settled, but it can resolve a specific question before money changes hands.
Timing and the mechanics
An application needs a full description of the transaction, the parties, the commercial purpose, the statutory provisions relied on and the documents. HMRC will not advise on a proposal that is still being designed, and an application that leaves out a step in the structure will produce a clearance that does not cover the transaction that actually happens.
In practice the application should be made as soon as the structure is settled and before exchange, so that the clearance is in hand at completion. If it is not, the sale agreement should make receipt of a satisfactory clearance a condition of completion, with a long-stop date and a clear position on what happens if it is refused or granted on terms.
If the transaction changes after the application, apply again or at least notify HMRC. A clearance obtained on one set of facts does not cover a different one, and the temptation to proceed on the basis that the change is immaterial is exactly the kind of judgement that looks bad in hindsight.
The other tax steps in a sale
Clearance is not the only tax point in a transaction. On an asset sale the transfer of a business as a going concern may be treated as outside the scope of VAT, provided the conditions are met and the buyer is registered and intends to carry on the business — the option to tax on the property can defeat that, so check it early.
Stamp duty land tax, or the Welsh and Scottish equivalents, applies to the transfer of land and to the grant or assignment of a lease, and on an asset sale it applies to the property element of the price. Employee share schemes need employment related securities filings and often a valuation agreed with HMRC's share valuation team, which can take considerably longer than the deal allows.
Termination payments, restrictive covenant payments and payments for goodwill between connected parties each carry their own treatment, and each is commonly misapplied in small transactions where nobody has looked at the allocation of the price. The allocation in the sale agreement is what HMRC will see.
Coordinating it with the deal
The parties should agree early who is responsible for which application, who bears the cost, and what happens if clearance is refused. In a share sale the seller's shareholders benefit from the relief, so the seller usually applies, but the buyer will want to see the clearance and may need its own on the buyer side of the structure.
Keep the correspondence together and treat it as confidential. Clearance applications contain the commercial rationale for the transaction and sometimes more detail about the business than the seller would want in the data room. They belong in the deal file, not in the disclosure pack.
If you are planning a sale or a reorganisation and want to know what the legal work will cost, ask us for a quote. We will price the transaction on the facts you give us and set out the clearances and filings it will need before you commit.
Selling or buying a business? Get a fixed-fee quote for the legal work before you agree terms.
Get a quote