The legal difference that matters
A lease grants exclusive possession of defined premises for a term, in exchange for rent. It is an interest in land: it can be bought, sold, charged, and it binds a new owner of the building. A licence is merely permission to occupy and use premises, given on terms, and it creates no interest in land at all.
The practical consequences are substantial. A leaseholder has security for the term and can generally only be removed for breach. A licensee can be required to leave when the licence ends, and in some circumstances on short notice. A lease can be assigned or used as security for borrowing; a licence generally cannot.
The trade-off is obligation. A lease brings repairing, insuring and service charge liabilities, often over several years, plus dilapidations at the end. A licence is lighter, shorter and cheaper to document — which is why it suits serviced offices, co-working, short-term projects and concessions.
When a licence is genuinely appropriate
Licences work well for short-term, low-commitment arrangements: a hot desk in a shared workspace, a pop-up shop for six weeks, a storage bay, an advertising concession, or a contractor needing access to perform services on site. The occupier wants flexibility and the provider wants to retain control of the space and its management.
They are unsuitable where the occupier needs to invest in the space, where the business depends on being at that address for several years, or where the premises must be shown as an asset to a lender or a buyer. Fitting out premises you occupy under a licence is a capital investment in someone else's property with no legal protection.
A licence should also be genuinely structured as one: the provider must retain control, provide services, and be able to relocate or manage the space as the agreement describes. A licence that gives the occupier exclusive possession of a self-contained unit, at a rent, for a fixed term, with no services, will look like a lease to a court whatever it is called.
The reclassification risk
The courts look at substance, not labels. If an agreement described as a licence confers exclusive possession for a term at a rent, it is likely to be construed as a lease. The consequences fall mostly on the provider: unexpected security of tenure, restrictions on recovering possession, and a property interest that may need to be disclosed on a sale or to a lender.
For the occupier, reclassification is not necessarily good news either. A licence that turns out to be a lease may bring repairing obligations the occupier never priced, a longer commitment than intended, and a dispute about the terms that were never agreed.
The safe course is to align the document with the reality: if the arrangement is effectively a letting of a defined unit for a term, use a lease. If it is genuinely a service-based, flexible arrangement, use a licence drafted to reflect that. Anything in between should be described accurately and reviewed by someone who understands the difference.
Tax, rates and practical consequences
The structure affects more than occupancy rights. VAT treatment of licence fees can differ from rent; business rates liability usually falls on the occupier whatever the document says; and the tax treatment of a premium or a fit-out contribution depends on whether the occupier holds an interest in land.
It also affects what happens if the building is sold. A lease binds the buyer of the freehold; a licence generally does not, and the occupier may find the new owner unwilling to continue the arrangement. On any arrangement longer than a few months, occupiers should ask what happens on a sale of the building.
We draft and review both leases and licences for commercial occupiers and for landlords, and we will tell you which structure your arrangement actually needs rather than simply papering what has been proposed.