How hourly billing behaves in a small business
Hourly billing works well for projects with a defined end. It works badly for the steady drip of small questions a trading business generates, because each question carries a price and the honest calculation most owners make is that the question can wait.
So it does. A customer's amended terms are signed unread. A supplier's new clause goes unchallenged. A disciplinary is handled by the manager who has never run one. None of those decisions feels like a legal decision at the time, and all of them become one later, at several times the cost of the original question.
There is also the minimum-charge problem. A query that takes eight minutes cannot be billed as eight minutes, so it gets billed as a quarter of an hour plus a file opening, or it does not get asked at all. Either way the economics push the wrong way.
What a subscription changes
A subscription moves the marginal cost of asking to near zero. That does not make the advice free — you have paid for the month — but it changes behaviour, and behaviour is most of the value. Questions get asked at the point of decision rather than after the problem.
It also lets the solicitor see the pattern. Somebody who answers one question a year can only answer that question. Somebody who has seen the last six months of contracts, complaints and staff issues can tell you that this one is the third version of the same problem, which is a different and more useful piece of advice.
The predictable cost is worth something on its own. A fixed monthly figure can be budgeted; a legal bill that arrives after a bad quarter cannot.
Where hourly still wins
One-off transactions: a business sale, a property purchase, an investment round, a settlement. These are projects with a scope, a timetable and a risk profile, and they should be quoted properly rather than absorbed into a retainer.
Litigation is the other obvious case. Nobody can predict how a claim will run, and pretending otherwise produces either an unhappy client or an unsustainable subscription. The healthy arrangement is a subscription for the routine and a separate, discounted quote for the exceptional.
A business that genuinely has one legal question a year should not buy a subscription. Twelve months of fees for a single contract review is not a good trade, and any adviser who says otherwise is selling rather than advising.
The arithmetic, roughly
Take a business with two employment questions, three contract reviews, a terms update and a handful of short calls in a year. On hourly rates that is a bill in the low four figures, plus the questions it decided not to ask. On a subscription it is a known monthly cost, and the decisions were made with advice.
The comparison only works if the subscription is actually used. A retainer nobody calls is an insurance premium; a retainer used monthly is a legal function. Our subscription is priced for the second, and we say so at the start: if you do not expect to use it, do not buy it.
If you want the numbers for your own business, the page on what it costs to instruct a small business solicitor sets out the alternatives side by side.