Three mechanisms
A rent review clause resets the rent during the term. The common mechanisms are open market review, where the rent is set at what the premises would let for on the open market at the review date; indexation, where rent increases by reference to a published index such as RPI or CPI; and turnover rent, where rent is calculated by reference to the tenant's sales, sometimes with a minimum.
Open market reviews dominate in the UK, usually on an upwards-only basis, which means the rent can rise but never fall. That asymmetry is a legacy of long institutional leases, and it is the single most valuable term a tenant can negotiate against — a review that can go down as well as up is worth real money over a ten-year term.
Indexed reviews are increasingly used for shorter leases and for smaller units, because they are cheap to operate and certain in outcome. They are transparent, but they carry inflation risk: an index-linked review in a period of high inflation can move rent far more than the local market would justify.
The assumptions that set the rent
In an open market review, the hypothetical letting is defined by a set of assumptions and disregards that materially change the answer. Typical assumptions include that the premises are available to let on the open market, that the tenant has complied with its obligations, that the premises are in good repair, and that no work is needed to put them in that state.
The disregards usually include any effect of the tenant's occupation, goodwill and improvements, so that the tenant is not charged rent for its own investment. Those disregards need to be drafted precisely — a broadly worded improvement disregard protects a tenant who has spent money on the premises; a narrow one may not.
Where the premises are part of a building, the review will also assume the building is in good condition and the services are being provided. Read together with the service charge, the effect can be that the tenant pays for a standard of building it has never actually received.
Procedure and default
Most clauses set a timetable: the landlord serves a notice proposing a rent, the tenant responds, and if the parties do not agree the matter goes to an independent expert or an arbitrator. Each step has a time limit, and failing to respond within it can be treated as acceptance of the landlord's figure — a trap that catches tenants who assume silence is neutrality.
The choice between expert determination and arbitration matters. An expert decides on the evidence and the valuation; an arbitrator decides on the parties' cases. Expert determination is quicker and cheaper, but it gives the parties less control over the arguments and, in general, no right of appeal.
If the review is not completed by the review date, the clause usually provides that rent continues at the old rate until it is, then the difference is backdated. That is a cash-flow point rather than a legal one, but it should be budgeted for: a review concluded eighteen months late can produce a substantial back payment.
Negotiating the review
Before signature, ask four questions. Can the rent go down as well as up? Is there a cap on any increase, whether as a percentage or as a reference to an index? Can the landlord's proposal be challenged without the risk of paying the landlord's costs? And does the mechanism survive a break — a rent reviewed upwards shortly before a break date is a classic trap.
For a shorter lease, an indexed review with a cap is often better than an open market review with a costly dispute procedure. For a longer lease with a fitting-out investment, an open market review with firm disregards for the tenant's improvements is usually worth more than a cap, because it protects the tenant's own capital.
Diary every review date with the response deadline attached, and check the notice when it arrives rather than months later. A rent review is a negotiation with a deadline, and the tenant who engages first generally does better than the tenant who argues about the procedure afterwards.