The most common sale, and the least planned
More businesses pass to a family member than are sold to a trade buyer, a private equity house or a management team. Very few of those transfers begin with a written plan. They begin with an assumption — that the eldest will take over, that the children will sort it out between them, that the founder will keep an eye on things for a few years.
The assumption is usually kind and often correct, but it leaves three questions unanswered: what the departing owner is paid, what the successor owns, and what happens to everyone else. Each of those becomes much more expensive to answer once the founder has stopped working.
The families who do this well treat it as a commercial transaction with an emotional dimension, rather than an emotional transaction with a commercial dimension. That means an independent valuation, proper documentation and a timetable, agreed while everyone is still on speaking terms.
Pricing it fairly
There are three defensible approaches. The first is an independent valuation at market value, treating the family buyer exactly as a third party would. The second is a discounted price, reflecting the fact that the buyer is family and that the seller wants the business to survive rather than maximise the cheque. The third is a gift, in whole or in part, funded by the seller's own tax planning rather than by the business.
Whichever is chosen, the reason should be written down. A file note recording that the price was set at market value, or deliberately below it for stated reasons, protects both parties if HMRC or another family member asks later. It also protects the relationship: a price agreed in a solicitor's office is a decision; a price agreed at Christmas is a grievance waiting to happen.
If more than one child is involved, the fairest arrangements separate ownership from employment. The child who runs the business buys the shares; the others receive value in another form — property, investments, an equalising gift or insurance proceeds. Leaving one child with the business and the others with nothing but an expectation is the classic route to a family dispute.
Structures that work
A straightforward share sale from parent to child is the simplest route where the buyer can raise the money. Where they cannot, an earn-out or deferred consideration allows the price to be paid out of future profits, which aligns the interests of both generations: the seller is paid only if the business continues to perform.
Company purchase of own shares is often used where the company itself has the cash to buy the departing shareholder out. It is tax-efficient in the right circumstances, requires the company to have distributable reserves, and needs careful drafting to satisfy the statutory conditions.
Employee ownership trusts have become a genuine alternative for owners who want the business to stay independent and the staff to benefit, and they can be structured so that the owner is paid over time with a tax exemption on the sale proceeds. For a family business where no successor is willing, it is worth considering alongside a trade sale.
Whatever the structure, the documents are the same in outline: a share purchase agreement, board and shareholder approvals, new articles or a shareholders agreement reflecting the new ownership, and the practical steps — bank mandates, insurances, payroll, pensions, contracts and registrations.
The tax questions that decide the structure
The seller will want Business Asset Disposal Relief where it is available, which requires the shares to have been held for the qualifying period and the company to be a trading company. Relief has been restricted in recent years, so the arithmetic needs to be run early rather than assumed.
Gifts between family members raise capital gains and inheritance tax questions in both directions. Holdover relief can defer a gain on a gift of trading shares, and business property relief may apply to the value transferred, but the conditions are technical and the interaction between the two is where mistakes are made. Lifetime gifting also has to be squared with the seller's own retirement income.
If property is involved — a factory, a farm, a shop — the transfer of the building is a separate transaction with its own stamp duty land tax analysis, and transferring it to a company can trigger a charge. Where the trading premises are owned personally and used by the company, the lease arrangement between the two needs to be regularised before the shares change hands, not after.
Making it work in practice
Set a date for the handover of control, and keep to it. The most common cause of failed family succession is a founder who sells the shares but not the authority, leaving the successor accountable for results they cannot control and the staff unsure who decides. A written plan for the transition of decision-making is worth more than any clause in the sale agreement.
Then review the plan every year. Circumstances change, children change their minds, marriages happen, health fails. A succession plan is not a document you sign once; it is an arrangement you maintain.
If you are considering a family transfer, we can value the business, model the tax outcomes and draft the documents so that the commercial deal and the family relationships are protected in the same exercise.
Selling or buying a business? Get a fixed-fee quote for the legal work before you agree terms.
Get a quote