The event nobody plans for
In a company with two or three shareholders, the death of one is not only a personal tragedy; it is a governance event. The shares pass to the deceased's estate, the personal representatives become the registered holders once probate is granted, and until then the company may be unable to pass the resolutions that need a particular majority.
The practical consequences arrive quickly. Bank mandates need updating. Board meetings become inquorate. A sale that was being negotiated stalls because the seller cannot sign. The surviving shareholders discover that they are in business with people they have never met, who may want cash rather than a share of a company they know nothing about.
None of this is unusual, and all of it is preventable with two documents that most small companies do not have: suitable articles of association and a cross-option agreement.
Articles and cross-option agreements
The articles of association can include pre-emption rights on death, compulsory transfer provisions and a mechanism for valuing the shares. Without them, the default position is that the shares simply pass to the estate, and the surviving shareholders have no right to buy them.
A cross-option agreement is the more robust solution. Each shareholder grants the others an option to buy their shares on death, and grants the company an option to require them to sell. On death, the estate can require the survivors to buy, and the survivors can require the estate to sell. The price is fixed by an agreed formula or a named valuer.
The agreement is usually backed by life insurance written under trust, so the money to buy the shares exists when it is needed. Without the insurance, the surviving shareholders may have the right to buy and no means to pay, which converts a legal protection into a difficult conversation.
Probate, and who can actually sell
Until probate is granted, the personal representatives have no authority to deal with the estate's assets, including the shares. That can take months, and in a company where the deceased held the controlling interest, the business may effectively be in limbo.
Once probate is granted, the personal representatives can sell. They have a duty to obtain the best price they reasonably can, which means they may not simply honour a pre-agreed figure if the business has grown substantially since the agreement was signed. This is why valuation mechanisms in cross-options need review — a formula that has not been revisited in a decade may produce a number the estate cannot justify accepting.
If the shares are to be sold to a third party, the articles will usually require the other shareholders to be offered them first, and the buyer will need to be satisfied about the company's records, contracts and tax position in the usual way — with the added complication that the seller's knowledge died with the shareholder.
Tax and practical points
Inheritance tax may be due on the value of the shares, and business property relief may reduce it substantially if the company is a qualifying trading company and the shares were held for long enough. The interaction between relief, the estate's other assets and the timing of any sale needs to be planned with the estate's advisers.
The estate may be able to claim relief on a sale shortly after death if the shares are sold to a qualifying purchaser, which can materially improve the outcome for beneficiaries. That relief has conditions and time limits, so a sale should not be allowed to drift.
On the company side, the death of a director triggers an obligation to notify Companies House, and the loss of a key person may trigger covenants in bank facilities, customer contracts or leases. Those should be checked in the first week, not the first month.
What to do now
If you are a shareholder in a small company and cannot say what would happen to your shares if a fellow shareholder died tomorrow, that is the gap to close. Review the articles, put a cross-option agreement in place, insure it, and review the valuation formula every few years.
If a death has already happened, the immediate priorities are to establish who has authority, protect the trading position and take advice on the estate's options early. We can act for companies, shareholders and personal representatives in both situations.
Selling or buying a business? Get a fixed-fee quote for the legal work before you agree terms.
Get a quote