What a warranty is, and what it is not
A warranty is a statement of fact about the business that the seller promises is true. If it is untrue, the buyer has a claim for breach. It is not a guarantee that the business will perform; it is a promise that the accounts were prepared on a consistent basis, that the contracts listed are the contracts that exist, and that nothing material has been omitted.
The distinction matters because buyers often expect warranties to cover commercial expectations — that a customer will stay, that a margin will hold. They will not, and a seller will not give them. Warranties cover facts about the past and the present, which is why the due diligence exercise and the warranty schedule are two halves of the same thing.
The warranty schedule in a mid-market business sale is long, usually between thirty and sixty items across accounts, contracts, employment, property, intellectual property, tax, litigation and compliance. It is long because each statement shifts a specific risk to the seller, and the buyer wants the risks shifted.
Disclosure: the seller's shield
A warranty is defeated to the extent it is disclosed against. The disclosure letter, prepared by the seller's solicitor and delivered at completion, sets out the facts that make a warranty inaccurate — either generally, by attaching documents, or specifically, by describing the matter. A disclosed warranty cannot found a claim.
This is why the disclosure exercise is the most important work the seller's solicitor does. A seller who refuses to disclose something awkward, hoping it will not be noticed, converts a known issue into an unknown liability. A seller who discloses it fully has no liability for it at all.
Disclosure has limits: it must be fair and specific, and a disclosure of a document is generally a disclosure of its contents. Buyers should read the disclosure letter line by line, because accepting a broad general disclosure can quietly remove protection the warranties appeared to give.
Indemnities: pound-for-pound protection
An indemnity is different in kind. It is a promise to reimburse a specific loss, typically tax arising from a period before completion, or a specific known issue such as an unresolved employment claim or a defective title. Because it is a reimbursement rather than a damages claim, the buyer does not have to prove that a warranty was breached or mitigate in the same way.
Indemnities are also usually outside the financial cap that applies to warranties, which is why they are negotiated hard. A seller will resist an indemnity for everything and will usually accept one for a defined, quantified risk identified in due diligence.
The practical distinction for a buyer: warranties give broad coverage subject to caps and disclosure; indemnities give narrow coverage with fuller recovery. A well-constructed agreement uses both, and the argument is about where the line between them sits.
Caps, baskets and time limits
Three mechanics decide what a warranty is actually worth. The cap: the maximum the seller will pay, commonly a percentage of the price for general warranties with a higher figure for tax and title. The basket or de minimis: the threshold below which small claims are ignored and above which claims are made, sometimes on an aggregate basis.
Time limits: general warranties typically survive for twelve to twenty-four months, tax and employment matters longer. Claims must be notified within the period, and the definition of notification matters — a vague letter that does not identify the claim may not be enough.
Beyond the caps sits the reality that the seller is often the only source of recovery. A buyer should consider whether the seller's covenant is worth much after completion, whether part of the price should be held in retention or escrow, and whether warranty insurance is worth the premium. We draft and negotiate warranty and indemnity packages on both sides of business transfers and will tell you which fights are worth having.