Each model charges for something different
A day rate is the easiest to compare and the least informative. It tells you what an hour of somebody's time costs, and nothing about what you get for it. Two consultancies at the same rate can deliver wildly different amounts of progress, and the invoice will look identical either way.
A fixed fee prices a defined scope. The consultancy carries the risk of how long it takes, which is why the scope has to be written down precisely, with assumptions and exclusions, and why a fixed fee for a badly defined scope always gets re-scoped.
A retainer prices access and continuity: a defined number of days a month, or ongoing advisory support, for an agreed period. It suits work that has no natural end — a finance function being rebuilt, a board that needs a steady hand on strategy, a business in the middle of a transformation.
Why day rates reward the wrong thing
Day rates pay for presence. They reward the consultancy that takes longer, staffs the engagement more heavily and stays in the room, and they penalise the one that solves the problem in a week and leaves.
That is not a comment on integrity. It is what the commercial structure does, and most buyers know it even if they do not say so. The result is that day-rate engagements drift towards activity reporting: workshops held, interviews done, days consumed.
The honest use of a day rate is for genuinely open-ended work where neither side can define the end state — an investigation, a diagnostic, expert input into somebody else's project. In those cases the certainty of a fixed fee would have to be bought with a large contingency anyway.
How a fixed fee should be built
A properly built fixed fee has three parts: the deliverables, the assumptions, and the change mechanism. Deliverables are the things you would be able to hold in your hand or read on a page. Assumptions are the conditions that had to be true for the fee to work — access to data within two weeks, decisions from a named person within five working days, no change to the scope.
The change mechanism is the clause that saves the relationship. If an assumption fails, the fee changes by an agreed amount or the scope changes to fit, and neither side feels ambushed. An engagement with no change mechanism becomes a dispute about goodwill.
Phasing is the other practical protection. A fixed fee split into a diagnostic phase, a design phase and a delivery phase lets the client stop after phase one having spent a small fraction of the total, and lets both sides re-price with better information.
What to ask before you choose
Ask what the fee excludes. Ask which assumptions would change it. Ask who does the work — the senior person in the pitch or a team assembled afterwards — and ask what the deliverable will physically be.
Then ask what happens if the work finishes early, and what happens if it runs late. The answer tells you whether the pricing model is aligned with delivery or with billing.
We price management consultancy on fixed fees, phased, with the assumptions written into the proposal. It is a harder conversation at the start and a much shorter one at the end.