The usual reasons deals die
Business sales fail for a short list of reasons, and most of them appear late. Due diligence turns up something the buyer did not expect: a customer who is also a major creditor, an undeclared HMRC arrangement, a lease with three years left and no renewal right, or accounts that do not reconcile to the VAT returns.
Others fail for reasons nobody can fix. The buyer's funding is withdrawn. The lender's valuation comes in below the price. A key customer signals it will leave. The landlord refuses consent to assign. The buyer and seller cannot bridge a valuation gap that widened when the accounts were examined properly.
A meaningful proportion of deals that reach heads of terms do not complete. Treating that as a live risk, rather than a remote one, is what separates a sale that costs a few thousand pounds to abandon from one that costs the business its trading position.
Who pays their own costs
There is no rule of English law that the abandoning party pays the other side's costs. Each party bears its own unless the contract says otherwise — which is why heads of terms usually include a costs clause stating exactly that, and why that clause is one of the few that binds.
The practical effect is asymmetric. A buyer's abortive cost is usually legal and accountancy fees. A seller's abortive cost includes those, plus management time diverted from the business, staff who have been told a sale is coming, customers who have heard a rumour, and a damaged relationship with the buyer if the buyer is a competitor who now knows everything.
Where the sale agreement has been exchanged and one side then refuses to complete, the position changes: the innocent party can claim damages, including wasted expenditure in some circumstances, and can enforce the contract. That is a different situation from a deal that fails before exchange, and much rarer.
When wasted costs can be recovered
Recovery is possible where the other side has breached a binding obligation — broken exclusivity, misrepresented the position, or used confidential information for an improper purpose. It is possible where a party negotiated in bad faith having no intention of completing, though that is hard to prove and rarely worth the cost of trying.
It is also possible to agree a break fee, under which a party pays a stated sum if it withdraws. Break fees are uncommon in small business sales and are sometimes resisted as discouraging buyers, but a modest, mutual break fee is a legitimate way of making an unserious buyer think twice.
In practice, a claim for abortive costs on a sale that failed at due diligence will often cost more to pursue than it recovers. Sellers should assume the spend is sunk and make the process cheap enough to absorb, rather than plan to litigate it back.
Designing a process that survives failure
Do the work that removes buyer risk before you market. Tidy the company records, obtain landlord consents or at least a clear answer on them, resolve or disclose the HMRC issue, and have the disclosure letter's subject matter mapped in advance.
Stage the legal spend. Heads of terms, confidentiality and exclusivity cost very little. Due diligence support and the sale agreement are the expensive parts, and they should not be funded until the buyer has demonstrated it can pay and has committed to a timetable.
Fixed fees help here more than anywhere else. When the cost of the sale is known in advance, a failed process has a defined price, and the decision whether to try again with a different buyer is a commercial one rather than a financial shock. That is how we price business transfers.