Why pensions buy property
A self-invested personal pension or a small self-administered scheme can hold commercial property, and the tax treatment is attractive: rental income arises in the pension fund free of income tax, and gains on disposal are free of capital gains tax. For a business owner whose company occupies a building, the arrangement allows the pension to own the premises and the company to pay rent into the member's own retirement pot.
The attraction is real, but so are the constraints. A pension scheme is a trust with trustees who have duties, and the property must be an authorised investment that does not trigger a tax charge. The rules around connected parties, borrowing and occupiers are unforgiving, and the cost of a mistake is measured in tax charges rather than paperwork.
The result is that a pension purchase needs a solicitor, a pension administrator and usually an independent financial adviser working to the same plan, with the timetable built around the scheme's requirements rather than the seller's.
The permitted investment rules
Residential property is not permitted, with limited exceptions that should never be assumed. Commercial property — offices, shops, industrial units, warehouses, farmland and, subject to conditions, land — is generally permitted.
The scheme must not acquire an interest in taxable property from a member or a connected party, subject to limited exceptions where the property is business premises. Buying a building from the member's own company, or from the member personally, is where many proposed purchases fail at the first hurdle and need restructuring before contracts are exchanged.
Borrowing is permitted but capped, and the loan must be on commercial terms from a permitted lender. Where the scheme borrows to buy, the lender will require its own security and its own solicitor, and the timetable lengthens accordingly.
The lease to the trading company
Where the pension buys a building used by the member's company, the scheme grants a lease to the company. That lease must be on commercial terms: market rent supported by a valuation, a rent review pattern, repairing obligations, and a term that fits the scheme's investment strategy.
The rent must actually be paid, on time, and at the level the lease requires. Deferring rent to help the company's cash flow, or granting a rent-free period that was not envisaged, is a breach of the arm's length principle and can result in tax charges for the member.
The lease also needs to address what happens if the company fails, if the member retires, or if the property is sold. A pension-owned building with a tenant in administration is a problem for the scheme, and the trustees need the ability to re-let without the member's consent.
Practical points that delay completion
The seller and the seller's solicitor need to understand that they are dealing with a pension scheme, not a company. The buyer will be the trustees, the documents will be executed by trustees, and the funds will come from the scheme's bank account, which may need to be established before completion.
VAT is often the sticking point. Where the property is opted to tax, the buyer must be able to recover or account for VAT, and a pension scheme usually cannot recover it. That may mean the purchase has to be structured with a VAT-inclusive price, or the seller has to consider whether the option can be disapplied — which is not always possible.
Stamp duty land tax is payable by the scheme and is calculated in the ordinary way, but the interaction with the scheme's borrowing and the lender's requirements can affect completion mechanics. Build time into the timetable: pension purchases routinely take longer than the eight to twelve weeks a straightforward commercial purchase requires.
Getting the structure right first
The single most useful step is to have the pension administrator confirm in writing that the proposed purchase is permitted before heads of terms are agreed. That confirmation should cover the seller, the occupier, the borrowing and the VAT position.
Then instruct solicitors who are used to acting for pension trustees. The documents are similar to any commercial purchase, but the execution, the reporting obligations and the trustees' duties are not, and a scheme that acquires property improperly cannot simply unwind the transaction.
We act for SIPP and SSAS trustees and for business owners buying premises through their pension. If you are considering it, the earlier we are involved, the fewer structural surprises there are.