Why a joint venture rather than a purchase
A joint venture makes sense where one party has the land and the other has the capital, or where one has planning expertise and the other has development experience. Neither could achieve the outcome alone at acceptable risk, and the combination is worth more than the sum of the parts.
It also makes sense where the risk is too large for one balance sheet, or where the landowner wants to participate in the development profit rather than sell at a site value.
What a joint venture does not do is remove the need for a clear agreement. Partnerships formed on trust and a handshake are the ones that end in litigation, because the parties discover their assumptions differed only when a decision has to be made.
The vehicle: land, LLP or company
A land-owning joint venture can be structured in three main ways. The land can be contributed to a company or LLP in return for shares or interests. The land can be sold to the vehicle at market value. Or the landowner can retain the land and grant a development agreement or option to the developer.
Each structure has different tax consequences. Contribution relief, stamp duty land tax on transfers, capital gains treatment on a subsequent sale, and the availability of losses all vary. The structure should be chosen after tax advice, not before.
The company and LLP forms both provide limited liability and a constitution, but they differ in tax transparency and in how profits are extracted. For a small number of participants with a defined project, an LLP is often preferred; for a long-term investment with multiple investors, a company is more common.
The agreement that matters
The shareholders' or members' agreement is where the venture succeeds or fails. It must cover how decisions are taken, what requires unanimity and what can be decided by the majority, and who appoints the directors or managers.
It must also cover funding. What happens when the project needs more money than budgeted? Is each party obliged to contribute, diluted if they do not, or can one fund and take priority? Funding deadlocks are the most common cause of joint venture failure, and the mechanism should be agreed while relations are good.
Then the matters specific to property: who manages the development, what happens if planning permission is refused, how costs overrun are shared, what restrictions apply to a party transferring its interest, and what happens on death or insolvency of a party.
Exit and deadlock
Every joint venture should have an exit mechanism that does not depend on goodwill. Options include a right to require a sale of the property after a fixed period, a put and call option, or a buy-sell mechanism where one party names a price and the other chooses whether to buy or sell at it.
Deadlock provisions are the safety valve. Where a decision cannot be taken, the agreement should escalate it, then allow a defined resolution such as a casting vote, mediation, or ultimately the buy-sell mechanism. An agreement that leaves deadlock unresolved leaves the property stranded.
Finally, consider what happens at the end. The development profit has to be extracted, the property may need to be sold, and the vehicle wound up. Planning that exit at the start is much easier than negotiating it when the parties have differing views about timing.