Agriculture is a use of land, not a permission for everything
Land and buildings in agricultural use enjoy certain permitted development rights, but those rights are limited and conditional. A change of use from agriculture to something else is development, and it normally requires planning permission unless a specific permitted development right applies.
Diversification covers a wide range: farm shops, cafés, weddings and events, storage and light industrial uses, holiday lets, equestrian enterprises, offices and renewable energy. Each has a different planning route, a different parking and access implication, and a different effect on the planning status of the holding.
The threshold question is always the same: has the use changed from agriculture to something else? A farm shop selling produce grown on the farm is a long-established exception within limits. A shop selling bought-in goods is retail, and retail is not agriculture.
The permitted development routes
The General Permitted Development Order contains several routes relevant to farms. Agricultural buildings and operations benefit from limited permitted development, subject to size, location and prior notification requirements. Conversion of agricultural buildings to dwellinghouses has been available under a specific class, subject to prior approval on matters including transport, noise and contamination.
There are also classes allowing agricultural buildings to change to flexible commercial use — shops, restaurants, offices, storage and light industrial — again within floor-space limits and subject to prior approval. These routes are useful but narrow: they require an application for prior approval, they have conditions attached, and they do not override other consents such as listed building consent or environmental permits.
Where the proposal falls outside a permitted development class, a full planning application is needed, with the usual supporting material: access, parking, drainage, landscape impact, heritage and, for some uses, noise and odour. On a working farm, the relationship between the new use and the agricultural operation is often the deciding factor.
Tenancies and the landlord's position
If the farm is tenanted, diversifying may require the landlord's consent. An Agricultural Holdings Act tenancy typically restricts the use of the holding to agriculture, and a non-agricultural use without consent can be a breach. Farm business tenancies can be drafted more flexibly, but the agreement still governs.
Many AHA tenancies now include express provision for diversification, sometimes with landlord approval and rent adjustment. Where the tenant carries out permitted development conversions, the position on rent, at the end of the tenancy, and on compensation can be complicated, particularly where the tenant has created a valuable non-agricultural use.
Landlords should think about the long term. A diversified enterprise that becomes established may be hard to unwind, may affect the agricultural value of the holding for tax purposes, and may change what the land is worth at the end of the tenancy. Consent should be given deliberately, in writing, and on terms that deal with those consequences.
Tax and subsidy implications
Diversification can affect agricultural property relief and business property relief. Relief depends on the property being occupied for agricultural purposes, and a building converted to a holiday let or a commercial unit may fall outside agricultural relief — though it may qualify for business relief on its own terms. The analysis is fact-specific and should be run before the conversion, not after.
The environmental land management schemes and any remaining delinked payments also need checking: some agreements restrict non-agricultural use, and some activities may affect eligibility. Planning permission and scheme compliance are separate questions, and both must be answered.
Business rates, VAT treatment of holiday accommodation, and the capital allowances position all follow the planning use rather than the other way round. We advise on the planning and tenancy aspects and work with your accountant on the rest.