What is actually being granted
A grazing licence gives someone permission to graze livestock on land for a defined period. It creates no interest in the land, gives the grazier no security of tenure, and can generally be ended at the end of the agreed term. It suits seasonal arrangements: summer grazing, tack sheep, a few fields let for a few months.
A farm business tenancy grants the occupation and use of land for a business of agriculture for a term. It creates a legal interest in the land. The tenant has rights under the Agricultural Tenancies Act 1995, and the tenancy can be assigned or underlet only as the agreement allows.
The distinction matters most when the arrangement ends. A licence ends when it says it ends. A tenancy of more than two years must be a farm business tenancy, and ending a FBT properly requires the notices and procedures the Act sets out.
Where licences go wrong
The classic problem is a licence that behaves like a tenancy. If the grazier has exclusive possession of defined land, pays a periodic sum, and the arrangement continues past its stated end or is renewed repeatedly, a court may find that a tenancy has arisen regardless of what the document is called. Labels do not determine legal character; the substance does.
The risks of that outcome are substantial. An implied tenancy may bring security of tenure considerations under the 1995 Act, notice requirements, rent review rights, compensation for improvements, and a saleability problem for the landowner. A buyer of the land may find an occupier who cannot easily be removed.
The usual safeguards are: keep the term short and genuinely seasonal; do not grant exclusive possession of a defined area if it can be avoided; do not allow the arrangement to roll on indefinitely without review; and document each season separately. None of that guarantees a court's view, but it makes the intention unambiguous.
When a tenancy is the right answer
Where a farmer wants to let land to a business for a proper term, a farm business tenancy is the correct structure. It allows the parties to agree the length of the term, rent review, repairing obligations, permitted use, assignment and break clauses, and it gives the tenant the certainty needed to invest in the land and the business.
On terms over two years the FBT must satisfy the statutory requirements on the nature of the holding and the business of agriculture. Landlords should also consider whether a term of five years or more with a break clause is preferable to a shorter term: certainty for the tenant generally produces a better rent and a better-kept farm.
Both parties benefit from a written agreement that covers who repairs what, how the land must be farmed, what happens to growing crops and store stock at the end, and how disputes are resolved. A tenancy without those terms is not illegal, it is simply a dispute waiting for a date.
Practical drafting points
For a licence: state the term precisely, state that no tenancy is intended, give the licensor rights of access and inspection, require the grazier to keep the land in good heart and to remove stock on notice, and make clear who is responsible for fencing, water and liability. Provide for early termination in defined circumstances.
For a tenancy: deal with rent and review, insurance, repairs and dilapidations, the use of buildings, whether residential property is included, compliance with scheme agreements, assignment and underletting, the treatment of ingoing and outgoing valuations, and the notices required at the end of the term.
Where a landlord wants flexibility, the honest route is a short FBT with a break, not a licence that is really a tenancy. We draft both, and we advise landowners on whether an existing arrangement has drifted into something they did not intend.