Why a buyer wants them
When a business is sold, much of what the buyer pays for is goodwill — the customers who come back, the relationships, the reputation of the name. Goodwill of that kind walks out of the door with the seller unless something holds it in place. Restrictive covenants are that something.
The covenants usually come in four shapes: a non-compete, preventing the seller from running or being involved in a competing business; a non-solicitation of customers, preventing them from poaching the people they used to serve; a non-dealing covenant, preventing them from trading with those customers even if the customer approaches them; and a non-poaching covenant covering employees.
On a share sale the covenants are usually given by the selling shareholders, and sometimes by the company itself. On an asset sale they are given by the seller and, where the seller is an individual with the relationships, by that individual personally. That distinction matters when the seller is a company and the person the buyer is really worried about is its owner.
How far they can go
English law treats a covenant in restraint of trade as void unless it protects a legitimate interest and goes no further than reasonably necessary to protect it. The legitimate interest on a business sale is the goodwill that has been paid for. Protecting the buyer from ordinary competition is not enough.
Length, geography and activity are the three battlegrounds. Two to three years is common on a small business sale; longer periods are harder to justify unless the buying cycle is genuinely long. Geography should be tied to where the customers actually are, not to a convenient radius, and activity should be limited to the business the buyer has acquired, not to every trade the seller might follow later.
Courts will sever an unreasonable clause where the drafting allows it, and the modern approach is more willing to enforce covenants in a sale than in employment. But a covenant that has to be litigated is a covenant that has already cost someone money. A tighter clause that a seller can live with is usually worth more to a buyer than a broad one a court may strike out.
The seller's side of the bargain
Covenants are not one-way and they are not free. A seller giving up the right to trade in their own sector for two years is giving something of value, and a buyer will expect the price to reflect it. Some sellers ask for a carve-out for a passive shareholding, for employment with an unrelated group, or for a business in a different geography.
The other protection is precision. A seller should know exactly what is prohibited: does it cover a company they hold shares in? A consultancy they join? A family member's business? Vague drafting is a risk to both sides — the buyer cannot enforce it confidently, and the seller cannot plan around it.
Finally, the covenants should be read alongside the warranties and the disclosure letter. A restrictive covenant does not cure a misdescription of the business; it simply delays the day the seller can compete with it.
When a covenant is broken
The buyer's remedy is normally an injunction to stop the breach, plus damages or an account of profits where loss can be shown. Where the sale agreement contains an indemnity, the buyer may also claim under it. Speed matters, because courts are reluctant to grant an injunction where a buyer has sat on their rights.
A seller who thinks a covenant is too wide should not simply ignore it. The correct response is to negotiate before signing, or to seek a declaration that the clause is unenforceable — which is a much cheaper conversation before completion than after.
We draft and negotiate these covenants on both sides of the transaction, and we advise on what a seller should reasonably accept for the goodwill being paid for. If a covenant is being proposed that would stop you working in your own sector, get it looked at before you sign.