Two dates, two owners
On exchange the parties become bound. On completion the buyer pays and takes control. In between, the business is being run by the seller but has been promised to the buyer, and the question of who bears the risk of something going wrong in that window is settled by the sale agreement — not by common sense.
The default position differs between the property and the business. On a property transfer, risk usually passes to the buyer on exchange, which is why buyers insure from exchange and why the standard conditions deal with damage, requisitions and the like. On a business sale, the trading risk usually stays with the seller until completion, because the seller is still running the business and receiving its income.
That split is rarely obvious on the face of the agreement. It should be stated expressly, on both the assets and the property, because a fire in week three of a four-week gap will otherwise be argued about by two sets of insurers.
Running the business in the gap
The buyer needs the business preserved: ordinary course of trading, no material new liabilities, no disposals of assets outside stock, no changes to employee terms, no new long-term contracts without consent, and insurance maintained. The agreement should say all of that, and should also say who keeps the profits of the intervening period — normally the seller, since the seller bears the risk.
The seller needs to be able to trade without asking permission for every decision. The list of restricted matters should be narrow enough to operate and wide enough to protect the buyer, and it needs to be read by the people actually running the business day to day, not just by the directors who signed it.
Notification obligations matter more than they look. An obligation to tell the buyer promptly of anything that would breach a warranty or have a material adverse effect gives the buyer a chance to react and gives the seller protection if the buyer then completes without complaint.
When something does go wrong
Three mechanisms are used. A condition precedent is the bluntest: completion is conditional on a specified state of affairs, and if it is not met, either party may walk away. A price adjustment addresses changes in value, and is common where stock, debtors or cash are expected to vary — this is where completion accounts do their work.
A retention or holdback keeps part of the price back against a defined risk for a defined period. A specific indemnity is a pound-for-pound promise to cover a known problem, such as an unresolved HMRC enquiry or a disputed contract, and it survives the general limitations on warranty claims.
A material adverse change clause sits above all three and is the most argued over. Buyers want a right to walk away if trading falls materially; sellers resist because a clause like that hands the buyer an option over the business for the length of the gap. Where one is agreed, it should define the threshold numerically and exclude general market conditions and matters disclosed in the disclosure letter.
Keeping the gap short
The most effective protection is a short window. Exchange and completion on the same day is common in small business sales, and a gap of a week or two is usually enough to deal with releases, filings and payments. Long gaps are a feature of deals that depend on third parties — landlord consent, lender release, regulatory approval — and in those cases the gap is doing necessary work.
Where a long gap is unavoidable, the property and the business should be dealt with separately rather than in one document, so each risk sits where it belongs. Insurance should be reviewed by both sides at exchange, and the seller should keep cover in place until completion and cancel only when the buyer's cover is confirmed live.
We structure the interim provisions at the same time as the warranties, because the two are a single allocation of risk. A sale that is well drafted in the agreement and silent on the gap has left the most expensive question unaddressed.