Hope value, and who captures it
A commercial site with development potential is worth two different things: what it is worth in its current use, and what it is worth to someone who can obtain planning permission and build. The gap between them is hope value, and the central question in any land sale is who captures it.
Sell the site unconditionally to a developer and the buyer captures it. Retain the land and obtain planning permission yourself and you capture it, at the cost and risk of the application. Share the risk through an option or promotion agreement and the value is divided according to the deal.
The right answer depends on the site, the planning prospects, the seller's appetite for risk and the seller's need for cash. A seller with a strong planning case and time can do very well by taking the risk. A seller who needs certainty should price the site on its existing use and let the buyer take the upside.
The structures
An unconditional sale is the simplest: the seller is paid on completion and the buyer takes all the planning risk. The price reflects the risk, and the seller has no further interest in the outcome.
A conditional contract makes the sale subject to planning permission being obtained. The price is agreed, the buyer bears the application cost, and completion happens if consent is granted. Sellers should insist on a long-stop date, a requirement that the buyer pursues the application diligently, and a clear position on what happens if a consent is granted on terms the seller did not expect.
An option agreement gives the buyer the right, but not the obligation, to buy within a set period, usually in return for a fee. The seller keeps ownership and receives an option fee plus an agreed price if the option is exercised. Options are common for strategic land and for sites where the planning process will take years.
A promotion agreement is a joint venture: the promoter obtains planning permission at its own cost and the land is then sold on the open market, with the proceeds split. The seller keeps the land until sale and shares the uplift, which can produce a better outcome than an option but involves a longer relationship and more uncertainty.
Overage and clawback
Where the site is sold for its existing use value but has obvious potential, the seller can retain a share of any future uplift through an overage or clawback provision. The buyer pays a lower price now and a further sum if planning permission is granted, or if the developed site is sold within a defined period.
Overage is only as good as its drafting. The trigger must be precise, the calculation must be unambiguous, the period must be long enough to be meaningful, and the obligation must be registered against the title so that it binds subsequent owners. A poorly drafted overage is a promise the seller will spend years trying to enforce.
Think about the triggers carefully: the grant of a planning permission, the commencement of development, the sale of the developed units, or the occupation of the building. Each has different timing and different evidence requirements.
What to fix before you market
Establish the planning position. What is the site allocated for in the local plan? Is there a history of applications or refusals? Are there constraints — flood risk, contamination, access, heritage, protected species, utilities — that will shape what can be built? A planning consultant's appraisal is cheap relative to the price difference it can produce.
Establish the title position. Are the boundaries clear? Are there rights of way, covenants or easements that would prevent development? Is there a ransom strip? Is the access adopted highway or third-party land? Title defects that a developer discovers will cost the seller far more than they would cost to fix.
Establish the physical position. A phase one environmental assessment, a utilities search and a topographical survey will tell you what the site actually is. Contamination is the classic development surprise, and it is the seller who pays for it, either in the price or in an indemnity.
Marketing and negotiating
For a site with real potential, a competitive process is worth the effort. Approach developers, promoters and housebuilders with a pack containing the planning appraisal, the title, the survey information and a clear statement of what the seller is offering: freehold with vacant possession, subject to overage, or under an option.
Be explicit about what the seller wants. Certainty of price and timing, or a share of the upside? A clean exit, or a long-term interest in the site's development? The answer shapes the structure, and the structure shapes the price.
We advise landowners on conditional contracts, options, promotion agreements and overage, and can coordinate the planning and environmental consultants the site needs.