The early stage
Most complaints are commercial, not legal: a delayed delivery, a disputed invoice, work that does not match the specification. The instinct to explain, apologise and fix is usually right, but do it deliberately. An apology is not an admission of liability under the Compensation Act 2006, but an email conceding fault and promising a refund is evidence.
Keep a file from the first complaint: the contract, the correspondence, the specification, the delivery records and the photographs. Disputes are won with documents, and documents that were not kept at the time are expensive to reconstruct.
If a settlement is being discussed, mark the correspondence without prejudice so it cannot be put before a court later. If you are writing a formal response to an allegation, do not mix it with a settlement offer in the same letter.
The letter before claim
A letter before claim is a formal step required by the Pre-Action Protocol for debt claims and expected in most commercial disputes. It sets out the claim, the sum, the basis and a deadline — usually 14 or 30 days — for a response.
It must not be ignored. The protocol requires a reply, and a court will take a dim view of a party that failed to engage. Costs sanctions follow: a defendant who ignores a proper letter can pay more than the claim was worth.
If you are the one sending it, it should be accurate. A letter before claim that overstates the case, misstates the contract or threatens what you cannot deliver undermines the position it was meant to strengthen.
Settling on the right terms
Most commercial claims settle, and they settle at the point where each side understands the other's evidence. The mechanisms are well worn: a without prejudice offer, a Calderbank offer (without prejudice save as to costs), or a Part 36 offer where proceedings have started.
Part 36 is the one with teeth. A party that refuses an offer it should have accepted can be penalised in costs and interest, sometimes heavily. It is worth understanding before you dismiss an offer as too low.
Any settlement should be documented in a written agreement with a payment date, a confidentiality clause, a release of claims and a statement that it is in full and final settlement. An exchange of emails agreeing to 'sort something out' is not a settlement and will not protect you.
If it goes further
Claims are allocated to a track according to value and complexity. Small claims are cheap and informal but capped; the fast track and multi-track carry real costs exposure, including the other side's legal fees if you lose.
That exposure is why insurance matters. Professional indemnity, public liability or legal expenses cover may fund the defence, and the insurer's consent is usually needed to settle. Check the policy before you respond to a claim, not after.
The practical lesson for a small business is that the first two letters decide most of the outcome. Getting a solicitor to read the complaint before you reply costs a fraction of getting one to conduct the litigation.