Where post-completion disputes come from
The disputes that follow business transfers fall into a small number of categories. A warranty claim, where the buyer discovers something about the business that the seller warranted was not the case. An earn-out dispute, where the parties disagree about how the target was calculated. A completion accounts argument about stock, debtors or working capital. A restrictive covenant problem, where the seller is said to be competing or soliciting. And occasionally a claim that the seller misrepresented the business during the sale process.
Each is a document problem before it is a commercial one. The claim succeeds or fails on what the agreement says, what was disclosed, and whether the procedural requirements were followed. Buyers who negotiated a comprehensive warranty schedule but ignored the notification clause have lost claims that were otherwise strong.
The pattern is consistent enough that both sides should treat the agreement's dispute machinery as seriously as its commercial terms. It is the part that is only read once something has gone wrong.
The traps in the timetable
Warranty claims must usually be notified within a defined period — often twelve to twenty-four months for general matters, longer for tax — and the notification must typically identify the claim and, in some agreements, give a reasonable estimate of the amount claimed. A late or vague notice can extinguish an otherwise valid claim.
There is usually a further requirement that legal proceedings be issued within a set period after notification, typically six months. Buyers who notify and then negotiate indefinitely can find the claim has lapsed while they were talking. The right approach is to diary both dates and to issue proceedings where there is any risk of missing the second.
On the seller's side, the agreement will usually contain a mechanism for the buyer to conduct third-party claims — for example a tax enquiry — with the seller's involvement, and a requirement to mitigate. A seller who is not told about a claim until it has been settled cannot control it.
Earn-outs and completion accounts
Earn-out disputes usually begin with a disagreement about the accounts rather than the intention. Did 'revenue' include intra-group sales? Was a customer's rebate deducted before or after the threshold? Did the buyer's decision to change the sales team amount to a breach of the operating covenant? The answers depend entirely on definitions that were agreed, or not, at the outset.
Completion account disputes are more mechanical and often resolved by expert determination, which is faster and cheaper than litigation. That only works if the agreement provides for it, names the basis of appointment and sets a timetable. Where it does not, the dispute becomes a court claim about an accounting figure.
In both cases, evidence decides the outcome. Contemporaneous management accounts, board minutes, correspondence about the calculation and any record of the buyer's operating decisions all matter. Both parties should preserve them from completion, not from the moment the dispute begins.
Protecting the position
For buyers: read the notification clause before completion and diary the dates. Chase any known issue early rather than waiting for certainty. Where the claim is against a seller who may have distributed the proceeds, consider whether part of the price should have been retained or whether warranty insurance was the better answer.
For sellers: disclose fully, keep the disclosure letter and the documents behind it, respond to notifications within the contractual period, and take advice immediately on any claim that alleges fraud rather than breach — the exemptions and caps that protect a seller do not apply to dishonesty.
We act in post-completion disputes on both sides, and we would rather review an agreement before signature than argue about it two years later. Where a dispute is already live, the first step is usually a short review of the agreement and the correspondence to establish what position you actually hold.