Two questions, not one
Every farming family faces the same structural question twice: how should the land be held, and how should the trading business be held? They are separate questions, and the answer to the first is often different from the answer to the second.
The land may be owned personally, jointly, by a partnership, by a company, or by a trust. The trading business may be a sole trader, a partnership, an LLP or a company. Many farms combine a company trading business with land held personally and let to the company, which keeps the land outside the trading risk while the trading entity carries the employees, contracts and machinery.
The right structure depends on family circumstances, tax, borrowing and succession as much as on liability. It should be reviewed when circumstances change — a new generation joining, a retirement, a large borrowing, a diversification project, or a change in the tax treatment of reliefs.
Partnership
A general partnership is the traditional structure, and it has real advantages: it is simple, flexible and its profits are taxed on the partners directly. The partners own the assets jointly, the accounts are straightforward, and the family can be brought in without incorporation.
It also has one serious drawback: unlimited liability. Each partner is liable for the partnership's debts, jointly with the others, and a partner's personal assets — including land held outside the partnership but used by it — can be exposed. The Partnership Act 1890 fills in the gaps where there is no written agreement, and those default rules are rarely what a family would choose.
A written partnership agreement is essential. It should cover profit shares, capital accounts, drawings, decision-making, admitting and expelling partners, retirement, death, and what happens to the land and the tenancy if a partner leaves. Without it, a dispute or a death can force a sale of assets nobody intended to sell.
LLP and limited company
A limited liability partnership gives the flexibility of a partnership with the liability protection of a company. The members are not personally liable for the LLP's debts, and profits are taxed on the members. The trade-off is more formality: accounts are filed publicly, and the members' agreement needs to be well drafted to preserve the flexibility that makes an LLP attractive.
A limited company separates the trading business from its shareholders entirely. Profits are taxed at corporation tax rates, salaries and dividends are used to extract value, and the company can hold assets and employ staff in its own right. For a growing or diversified business with real commercial risk, incorporation is often the sensible step.
Both structures bring obligations: annual filings, statutory records, directors' or members' duties, and the need to document decisions. They also change the succession picture, because shares or interests can be transferred over time rather than all at once.
Keeping the land and the trade apart
Where the land is held outside the trading entity, the relationship between them needs a lease or a licence that would stand up if challenged — a proper rent, a documented term, and terms that reflect the market. A nominal or undocumented arrangement invites a challenge from HMRC and creates uncertainty if the trading entity fails.
There are tax consequences to every choice. Agricultural property relief and business property relief operate differently on land, buildings, trading companies and shares. Capital gains treatment on a future sale depends on how the assets have been held and used. None of that can be decided by a solicitor alone, and it should not be decided by an accountant alone.
We work on the legal side of the structure — partnership agreements, LLP and shareholder agreements, leases between related parties, and transfers of land between generations — alongside your accountant's tax planning. The documents are the easy part; deciding what the family actually wants to happen is the work.