What you are actually buying
A freehold purchase buys the land and buildings outright, indefinitely, subject to whatever rights and covenants affect the title. A leasehold purchase buys a term of years — a long lease, typically — with a landlord who retains the freehold and the obligations that go with it.
For occupiers, the choice is usually between buying the freehold of the building you trade from and taking a lease of it. For investors, it is between owning the asset and owning an income stream with a fixed end date.
The financial comparison is not simply price against rent. Freehold ownership brings capital appreciation, control and the ability to borrow against the asset, but also the cost of maintenance, insurance and empty property rates. Leasehold occupation brings flexibility, a known cost and a landlord to share the burden with, but also service charges, consent requirements and a term that will eventually expire.
Control and flexibility
A freeholder can alter the building, change its use (subject to planning), sublet, sell or mortgage it without asking anyone. That control is worth a great deal to a business that expects to grow, reconfigure or sell.
A leaseholder is constrained by the lease. Alterations need consent, changes of use may be restricted, assignment and underletting are usually conditional, and the landlord's reasonable consent can still take weeks. The lease also determines what happens at the end of the term, and whether you have any right to renew.
For a business with a short expected lifespan in a location, or one that values the ability to move, a lease is often the better answer. For a business that intends to stay, own and eventually sell, freehold usually wins.
Cost over the long term
Leasehold occupation converts capital into rent, service charge and insurance rent. Those costs are predictable in the short term but exposed to review and to the landlord's management. A service charge that looks reasonable in year one can look very different in year five, and the tenant has limited ability to control it beyond the right to challenge reasonableness.
Freehold ownership converts rent into mortgage payments, maintenance and insurance. The costs are less predictable in any given year — a roof is not a budget line until it fails — but they are within the owner's control, and the capital value remains with the owner at the end.
The comparison should be run over the period you expect to occupy. Ten years of rent at a reviewed level, plus service charge and the cost of dilapidations at exit, is often more than the cost of buying, financing and maintaining the same building. But that comparison depends on the price, the borrowing rate and the location.
The exit
On a freehold sale, the owner receives the market value of the property, subject to tax and any mortgage. On a leasehold exit, the tenant either assigns the lease, sublets it, or serves notice and leaves — and each of those has a cost. Dilapidations at the end of a lease can be substantial, particularly under a full repairing obligation with an old schedule of condition.
For investors, leasehold interests shorten as the term runs down, and a lease with less than eighty years unexpired becomes harder to sell and harder to mortgage. Lease extensions are possible but cost money and time, and the statutory right to extend applies to leases of flats and houses, not to most commercial leases.
The exit should be considered at the point of purchase. If the plan is to sell in ten years, the tenure you buy now determines who will want to buy it then.
How to decide
Four questions usually settle it. How long do you expect to occupy? Does the business need to be able to change the building or its use? Can you fund a purchase, and at what cost of borrowing? And what does the exit look like — a sale of the asset, or the assignment of a lease?
If the answers point to a lease, negotiate the terms properly: the term, the break, the rent review, the repairing obligation and the alienation provisions. If they point to freehold, treat the purchase as an investment as well as an occupation, and have the title, the planning position and the building surveyed before you commit.
We advise occupiers and investors on both routes, including the comparison between them, before a decision is made.